CHICAGO – Different isn’t bad and might be great, but you’d better have an irrefutable reason to change what was never broken. Campy being the only word to accurately convey this alternate-reality version of Sherlock Holmes with an original script, writer Greg Kramer and director Andrew Shaver try too hard to be different without ever figuring out why.
Blu-ray Review: Neon Brilliance of Michael Mann’s Influential ‘Thief’
Michael Mann’s “Thief” is a crime movie that’s more about the criminal than his illegal acts. It’s about a man who has been torn down to nothing who slowly puts pieces back into his life, like a love affair and a family, only to learn that he has to give all of them up for his own safety. It’s a fascinating film, stunning in its technical acumen and with stellar performances from James Caan, Tuesday Weld, and Robert Prosky (making his film debut). It’s also a great inclusion in The Criterion Collection, perfectly remastered and with some interesting interview insights.
What is “Thief”? Like most Michael Mann films, it’s hard to pin down into a genre. Yes, there are traditional elements of the crime film and even some degree of noir but it’s so distinctly character driven that it transcends the cliches of its genre. Who is Frank (Caan)? He’s a jewel thief but he makes clear both to his new employer (Prosky) and his love (Weld) that he is not attached to anything or anyone. He goes on his own. He is a loner and “Thief” actually has thematic echoes of the Western more than a noir or crime flick.
Mann’s technical skill, which is practically unmatched in his generation, is fully on display this early in his career. The rain, the light, the neon, the flash of gunfire, the explosions & the blood — no one shoots a crime flick like Michael Mann. And yet the scene of the film, and arguably his career, is the diner scene about half an hour in. Jimmy Caan and Tuesday Weld are given about ten minutes to converse, to tell their back stories, and to fully ground these characters in ways that we don’t often get in literature, much less film. It’s one of my favorite scenes of all time.
And Caan says in the commentary track he shared with Mann that it’s his favorite scene of his career before the two gentlemen essentially go silent to watch it. The commentary track is strong but it was recorded two decades ago. More current are the interview special features, including new ones with Mann, Caan, and Tangerine Dream. Caan says he’s most proud of two or three pictures and “Thief” is one of ‘em. You can’t blame him.
Thief will be released on Blu-ray and DVD on January 14, 2014
Photo credit: Courtesy of the Criterion Collection
The contemporary American auteur Michael Mann burst out of the gate, his bold artistic sensibility fully formed with Thief, his first debut feature. James Caan stars, in one of his most riveting performances, as a no-nonsense ex-con safecracker planning to leave the criminal world behind after one final diamond heist, but discovering that escape is not as simple as he hoped. Finding hypnotic beauty in neon and rain-slick streets, sparks and steel, Thief effortlessly established the moody stylishness and tactile approach to action that would define such later iconic entertainments from Mann as Miami Vice, Manhunter, and Heat.
o Audio Commentary Featuring Mann and Actor James Caan
o New Interviews With Mann, Caan, and Johannes Schmoelling Of The Band Tangerine Dream, Which Contributed The Film’s Soundtrack
o Booklet Featuring An Essay By Critic Nick James