Frustrating Thriller ‘Wish You Were Here’ with Joel Edgerton

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionE-mail page to friendE-mail page to friendPDF versionPDF version
Average: 3.5 (2 votes) Oscarman rating: 2.5/5.0
Rating: 2.5/5.0

CHICAGO – There’s an honesty in the increasingly-great Joel Edgerton’s (“Animal Kingdom,” “Warrior,” “The Great Gatsby”) harrowing performance in Kieran Darcy-Smith’s “Wish You Were Here,” opening in New York and Los Angeles this Friday, that makes it a difficult film to dismiss. Sadly, the truth of what Edgerton brings to the role of a man who carries a dark secret is shrouded by a filmmaker who refuses to let us in on the cause of his pain. “Wish You Were Here” is a thriller/mystery that should have been a drama and feels more like it’s playing games with its audience than offering truthful characters or engaging storytelling.

“Wish You Were Here” opens with a lengthy montage of carefree behavior on a vacation in Southeast Asia. Alice (Felicity Price), her husband Dave (Joel Edgerton), Alice’s sister Steph (Teresa Palmer), and Steph’s new boyfriend Jeremy (Antony Starr) are gallivanting through Cambodia. Beautiful sights, friendly locals, a massive party around a bonfire, and a devastating betrayal that precludes a much-darker secret. The betrayal is revealed very early, so don’t consider this a spoiler –- on one of their last nights on vacation, very high and very drunk, Dave slept with Steph. More importantly, Jeremy didn’t come back with his three friends when they returned to Australia. Did he see his girlfriend’s betrayal? Did something awful happen to him at the party?

Wish You Were Here
Wish You Were Here
Photo credit: Entertainment One

As you might imagine, “Wish We Were Here” becomes an interchanging flashback/present-day story, as bits and pieces are revealed about that fateful night in Cambodia and Alice deals with the revelation that not only has her husband been unfaithful but with her sibling. Most interestingly, Dave clearly knows more about Jeremy’s disappearance than he’s letting on. He seems haunted by something, paranoid that he’s being followed or possibly even that Jeremy is back. Did he do something to him? What does he know? And is Jeremy dead or is the repetition of two scenes in which the young man talks about wanting to live in Southeast Asia forever meant to imply that he just ran away? And what exactly was Jeremy doing there in the first place? Was it more than a vacation?

Clearly, “Wish You Were Here” is a movie based on questions. Every scene gives a little bit more of the complete picture, like one of those puzzles that comes into focus gradually. The problem is that while Jeremy’s fate is an interesting story once revealed, it makes the rest of the film somewhat thin by not knowing it. There’s an incredibly strong drama buried in “Wish You Were Here” about a man keeping a harrowing secret but that drama only works if we know the secret in advance. I wanted so badly for “Wish” to lay its cards on the table and let us see their impact before the final scenes but realized, as it dragged its feet in the mid-section, that this wasn’t going to happen.

Wish You Were Here
Wish You Were Here
Photo credit: Entertainment One

“Wish You Were Here” would have been infinitely more interesting if told chronologically. The game-playing of the script defeats the honesty of the performances, particularly Edgerton. He’s hiding something dark but we have no idea what (it’s clearly more than just the sibling sex) and so it’s hard to care. And yet Edgerton never hits a false note. The increasing waves of paranoia and guilt he clearly feels is well-done. Edgerton keeps the viewer engaged when a lesser actor would have lost the narrative altogether due to the subterfuge of the script.

Joel Edgerton’s excellent performance (and Teresa Palmer shows some dramatic range that she’s not often given a chance to show) nearly justifies a view of “Wish You Were Here.” And yet, at the same time, all the unnecessary mystery placed on it weighs it down and makes what works about it that much more frustrating. It’s a vacation in which the guide book has been purposefully reordered and organized to disguise what would have been much more interesting told straightforward.

“Wish You Were Here” stars Joel Edgerton, Teresa Palmer, Felicity Price, and Antony Starr. It was written by Price and Kieran Darcy-Smith and directed by Darcy-Smith. It opens in New York and Los Angeles on June 7, 2013 and is rated R. content director Brian Tallerico

Content Director

User Login

Free Giveaway Mailing


  • YippieFest 2020 Logo

    CHICAGO – It’s coming! YippieFest 2020 – joining the virtual and online revolution during these particular times – is set for August 21st through the 23rd. Details to come on schedules and times, but the whole fest can be downloaded for FREE on those dates through TWITCH streaming service. Click here for more details.

  • Space Force

    CHICAGO – Seemingly ripped from the headlines, by way of “Dr. Strangelove,” the new Netflix TV series “Space Force” debuted on May 29th, 2020. Patrick McDonald of reviewed the series during the Eddie Volkman Show (Star 96.7 FM in Joliet, Illinois) on June 5th, 2020.

Advertisement on Twitter

archive Top Ten Discussions