Amy Seimetz Offers Startling Debut in ‘Sun Don’t Shine’

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionE-mail page to friendE-mail page to friendPDF versionPDF version
No votes yet Oscarman rating: 4.0/5.0
Rating: 4.0/5.0

CHICAGO – Every once in awhile, a year feels like it just belongs to a certain actor or actress. 2011 was the year of Jessica Chastain. It looks like 2013 could be the year of Amy Seimetz. She’s starring in the now-playing (and brilliant) “Upstream Color,” will appear on HBO’s “Family Tree” and AMC’s “The Killing” in the next few months, stars in the indie “Be Good” and acclaimed horror film “You’re Next,” and, this week, her directorial debut, “Sun Don’t Shine,” lands on VOD and in NY theaters before an expansion later this year. Like seemingly everything that Seimetz touches lately, it’s great. Confident, stylish, and with a remarkable sense of place, “Sun Don’t Shine” truly works.

“Sun Don’t Shine” opens with a fight. Crystal (Kate Lyn Sheil) and Leo (Kentucker Audley) are clearly under an immense amount of stress and not handling it well. As they argue over who started the fight and how intense it got, it becomes clear that Seimetz is jumping into her story in a unique place. Whatever sent these two on their combative road trip would typically be the first-act centerpiece of a drama but Seimetz cracks her narrative slowly, revealing the dark past and reason for the trip of her two characters one gruesome piece at a time. We see the fight, a tense roadside encounter, a gun in the glove compartment and something worse in the trunk. The dialogue is cryptic — “We can’t go to a motel. We got too much to do. We got to get to Terry’s bar by sunset.” — but indicative of past problems being fled and the likelihood of more problems in the future.

Sun Don't Shine
Sun Don’t Shine
Photo credit: Sun Don’t Shine

Crystal and Leo are likely to bring back echoes of Sissy Spacek and Martin Sheen in Terrence Malick’s “Badlands.” He is shirtless, stubbled, and looks older than his partner with the innocent face. (Seimetz also uses poetic narration and loves the natural look of her landscape in ways that echo Malick.) Leo is also clearly in charge in the relationship as Crystal is constantly trying to get his attention. After a fight, she offers they should go to a motel room to make love. After escaping a situation, she tries to go down on him. She’s more nervous about him finding sexual satisfaction with another than she is about what it is that has sent them fleeing across Florida. Leo is distant and practically dismissive of the needy Crystal. It begs the question as to why they’re together in the first place. They probably shouldn’t be but a joint secret makes a break up impossible now.

Few 2013 films will use setting as effectively as Seimetz does in “Sun Don’t Shine.” Florida is the third protagonist in the film and Seimetz, who grew up in the Sunshine State, knows how to use it. The heat, the freeways bordered by electrical wires, the flat landscape, inflatable alligators at gas stations, that damn insect sound that permeates the air — every detail of her setting seems of a piece and it’s certainly notable the way she uses sound just effectively (and one wonders if Shane Carruth, who similarly used sound for setting brilliantly in “Upstream Color” and produced this film, didn’t have some impact on the aural design). David Lowery, who edited “Upstream” and directed the Sundance award-winning and great “Ain’t Them Bodies Saints,” to be released later this year, does a great job editing here as well.

Sun Don't Shine
Sun Don’t Shine
Photo credit: Sun Don’t Shine

As for performance, both leads are good even if Sheil is a little off-putting at first. She can go from calm to wide-eyed, crying panic in the blink of an eye. It may seem too broad a performance but it’s consistent and so it starts to feel genuine. Crystal is unstable. And there are a lot of unstable girls who get caught up in bad situations. Audley plays Leo more distantly and quietly but is also quite effective. Both performances work.

And yet “Sun Don’t Shine” is primarily an achievement for its debut writer/director. Whereas so many filmmakers would have taken a traditional route with a relatively straightforward story, Seimetz feels like she already has a unique vision that could be an important one to the fabric of independent cinema. There are so many times in “Sun” where I just admired a shot choice (Seimetz loves the sun, which helps the feeling of menacing heat, either directly or from a low angle on one of her characters, framed by neverending blue and bright backlight) or storytelling decision. Her spare use of score, her daring narrative choices, her clear understanding of the importance of setting to a story that feels like it could only play out exactly like this in Florida. “Sun Don’t Shine” is unlikely to be the highest profile project for Amy Seimetz in her notable breakthrough year but, years from now, when she’s a highly-acclaimed writer & director as well as actress, it could be one of the most studied and remembered.

“Sun Don’t Shine” stars Kate Lyn Sheil and Kentucker Audley. It was written and directed by Amy Seimetz. It opens in New York on Friday, April 26, 2013 and is available on VOD now. content director Brian Tallerico

Content Director

Anonymous Woman's picture

I think it’s incredibly

I think it’s incredibly insulting and sexist for you to imply that elements of Seimetz’s film are good because of influence from Shane Carruth. Can’t a female director simply be good based on her own talent and merits?

BrianTT's picture

No insult was intended and I

No insult was intended and I apologize if one was inferred.

To clarify — Mr. Carruth won an award this year at Sundance for the Sound Design of a film in which Ms. Seimetz stars (Upstream Color). He also produced this film. I don’t think it’s out of the question to imply that his award-winning ability with sound design might have influenced the way Ms. Seimetz approaches the same and consider it a sign of her talent and merits that she uses sound as well.

I think I made clear how much I admired what Seimetz brought to the project as a director and writer but no filmmaker works alone, just as Mr. Lowery’s editing had an impact here and I praised Ms. Seimetz’s performance in Upstream Color. Implying the collaboration, especially one as creatively rewarding as Seimetz clearly has with Carruth (or Lowery), was never once meant as insulting or sexist.

BrianTT's picture

One More Thing

I absolutely, without hesitation, would have made the same connection if a man had directed the film. Mr. Carruth won an award for sound design and then a film was released that he produced that contained great sound design. It naturally inspires one to consider his influence, no matter the gender of the filmmaker.

Truth Teller's picture

fact check

You should be aware that Sun Don’t Shine premiered at SXSW long before Upstream Color even began shooting. It was Seimetz that actually recommended HER sound design person to Shane. So if anyone is influencing anybody else it’s the other way around.

You are one of three journalists that has now asked this woman if her male director friends have taught her how to do her job.

BrianTT's picture

Thanks and No, I Did Not

That’s great that Seimetz recommended her sound design guy to Shane. Thanks for the clarification. And it goes to my point that there was creative collaboration across the two films by the two people who made them. That’s ALL.

“didn’t have some impact,” which is what I wrote, is NOT “asking this woman if her male director friends taught her how to do her job.” Never thought it. Didn’t write it. And I think you know that. I praise numerous decisions Seimetz made. I understand the sensitivity of the subject but it’s simply untrue to equate a suggestion of creative collaboration between two people I CLEARLY see as talented as suggesting one “taught” the other.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

User Login

Free Giveaway Mailing


  • Manhunt

    CHICAGO – Patrick McDonald of appears on “The Morning Mess” with Dan Baker on WBGR-FM (Monroe, Wisconsin) on March 21st, 2024, reviewing the new streaming series “Manhunt” – based on the bestseller by James L. Swanson – currently streaming on Apple TV+.

  • Topdog/Underdog, Invictus Theatre

    CHICAGO – When two brothers confront the sins of each other and it expands into a psychology of an entire race, it’s at a stage play found in Chicago’s Invictus Theatre Company production of “Topdog/Underdog,” now at their new home at the Windy City Playhouse through March 31st, 2024. Click TD/UD for tickets/info.

Advertisement on Twitter

archive Top Ten Discussions