TV Review: Beloved ‘Doctor Who’ Returns with Stellar Series Premiere

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionE-mail page to friendE-mail page to friendPDF versionPDF version
No votes yet

CHICAGO – The good doctor is back in the TV office as “Doctor Who” returns tonight, September 1, 2012 for a five-episode run in which two characters will say goodbye and we will transition into the next phase of one of the most influential sci-fi shows of all time. Can “Doctor Who” survive without Amy and Rory? Can a show that has always adapted to change do so yet again? Of course. As long as the writing remains this impressive and consistent. Television Rating: 4.5/5.0
Television Rating: 4.5/5.0

How is it that “Doctor Who” can adjust its cast and tone so often and still remain creatively potent? It’s all about personality. As I watched the stellar premiere, “Asylum of the Daleks,” I was struck by how unique and instantly identifiable the world of “Doctor Who” has been for decades. Especially in its current reboot phase, the creators of “Doctor Who” have maintained a consistency of storytelling and vision that can be adjusted no matter who is in front of the camera. It never feels like “Doctor Who” is sacrificing its vision to appeal to a lowest common denominator or focus group. It is only loyal to its own history and its devoted audience, one that’s sure to be satisfied with a series 7 premiere that makes nods to the show’s past while also looking to its future.

Doctor Who
Doctor Who
Photo credit: BBC

The biggest nod to the past in the series 7 premiere of “Doctor Who” is right there in the title — “Asylum of the Daleks.” In the opening scenes, the Doctor (Matt Smith), Amy (Karen Gillan), and Rory (Arthur Darvill) are kidnapped by the Dalek Parliament and taken aboard a ship above a planet that is revealed to be the title of the episode — a spinning orb of the Daleks that were deemed crazy and uncontrollable. There’s a human shipwrecked on the planet sending a distress signal of classical music. Naturally, the concern is simple — as the Doctor says, “If something can get in, everything can get out.” They send the Doctor, Amy, and Rory in to determine the source of the signal before the entire asylum is shut down permanently.

Doctor Who
Doctor Who
Photo credit: BBC

“Asylum of the Daleks” (which was written by the brilliant rebooot show showrunner Steven Moffat and actually represents the writer’s first attempt at crafting a story for the legendary characters) reportedly features a visual incarnation of every Dalek from the long history of “Who” but it’s no mere ode to the iconic villains that still charmingly look like trash cans with flashlights taped to them. It’s a wonderful script with a spectacular series of twists in the final act that will leave “Who” fans smiling. The actual planet is built up as such a place of sheer lunacy that the art direction after the Doctor and his bickering partners get there is a bit of a letdown. I wanted a bit more creativity to the design of the Asylum but it’s a minor complaint.

All complaints I could levy at “Asylum of the Daleks” are minor. The massive hit (numbers for the show’s airings on BBC America keep rising every year) has lost none of its confidence, creativity, or, most importantly, personality. The show has such style, confidence, and sense of character that it’s easy to see why viewers have been so loyal to it for years. We’re only getting “Doctor Who” for one month this year (it will be on five episodes — every Saturday in September) but it’s going to be a fantastic month for sci-fi fans.

“Doctor Who” stars Matt Smith, Karen Gillan, and Arthur Darvill. The Series 7 premiere was written by Steven Moffat and directed by Nick Hurran. It premieres on Saturday, September 1, 2012 at 8pm CST. content director Brian Tallerico

Content Director

Rena Moretti's picture

Spoilers, ever???

Seriously, do you ever think of warning about spoilers?

That said, I’ll add that Doctor Who wasn’t always so good. When Russell Davies was running it, it looked like an amateur home video and completely boring and uninteresting.

Doctor who will remain good as long as Stephen Moffat stays on board.

He entirely re-invented the show with nary a trace of the nonsense of the Russell Davies years.

Noblelox's picture

Worried about Spoilers??? Why are you reading reviews then????

The episode has aired, this is a review, who wouldn’t expect a slight spoiler or two…obviously Rena Moretti… Do some people just scour the web looking for people who dare review a programme by pointing out story-lines. How are you suppose to review a programme without giving people an indication of what happens in the episode.

Did Brian say Bruce Willis was actually dead? or that the Butler did it? No he didn’t. Rena, rather than reading reviews that spoil the episode…GO AND WATCH IT….

Urko's picture

this embarrassing "review"

Is this what passes as journalism these days? This isn’t a review, it’s a gushing fan letter that a teenager might have written. How old are you, Mr Tallerico?

POD's picture

hardly seems logical....

Urko wrote:
Is this what passes as journalism these days? This isn’t a review, it’s a gushing fan letter that a teenager might have written. How old are you, Mr Tallerico?

So for it to be a review, you have to find massive faults and write nasty troll comments? Why couldn’t the reviewer not enjoy it?

Sure I can find more faults in the episode, but that is my geeky opinion. So why isn’t the reviewer allowed to express their opinion? I think you are the one being childish, by not being able to accept that other people have differing points of view.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

User Login

Free Giveaway Mailing


  • Importance of Being Earnest, The, Strawdog Theatre

    CHICAGO – Just in time for Pride Month, Strawdog Theatre Co. presents an updated staging of the Oscar Wilde classic, “The Importance of Being Earnest.” Strawdog policy … the tickets are FREE (donations encouraged), but you must put in a reservation by clicking EARNEST.

  • Prodigal Daughter, The

    CHICAGO – One of the open secrets of Chicago is its horrible racist past, which remains like an echo. Playwright Joshua Allen has been exploring this theme in his Grand Boulevard Trilogy – the last chapter talking place during the infamous 1919 race riots – in Raven Theatre’s “The Prodigal Daughter.” For tickets and info, click TPD.

Advertisement on Twitter

archive Top Ten Discussions