Blu-Ray Review: Great Cast Cannot Save Deeply Flawed ‘Stone’

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionE-mail page to friendE-mail page to friendPDF versionPDF version
No votes yet

CHICAGO – There was a time when the union of two actors as accomplished as Robert De Niro and Edward Norton would make movie news headlines. And, to be fair, John Curran’s “Stone” was chosen to open the Chicago Internation Film Festival in large part due to the pedigree of its stars. But viewers are smarter than they used to be. They know now that a movie’s success is not solely dependent on the talent of its leads. And while De Niro and Norton are two of our best actors (and they are amply supported by two great female turns as well), “Stone” just doesn’t work. Blu-Ray Rating: 2.5/5.0
Blu-Ray Rating: 2.5/5.0

The title of Curran’s semi-thriller refers to the nickname of Norton’s character, a con named Gerald Creeson who is up for parole and desperate to see the blue sky from more than just a prison yard. In fact, he’d like to see more than just sky as Stone also happens to have one of the hottest wives in the world, the lovely Lucetta (Milla Jovovich). Creeson talks a good game about redemption and seems to be honestly heading toward a second chance. Or is he? As with most parole situations, the question is if the convict is truly redeemed or merely manipulative.

The man tasked with answering that question is Jack Mabry (Robert De Niro), a bitter, angry fellow who seems beaten down by a life in a loveless marriage (to the great Frances Conroy). We know that the two have been miserable for decades because the film starts with a fascinating prologue in which Jack’s wife threatens to leave him and he essentially holds her captive through an even-greater threat. In thriller-speak, Jack is an easy target. He’s lonely, depressed, sullen, and listens to way too much religious radio.

Stone was released on Blu-Ray and DVD on January 18th, 2011
Stone was released on Blu-Ray and DVD on January 18th, 2011
Photo credit: Anchor Bay Home Video

So, when Lucetta pays Jack a visit and seduces him in order to get Stone’s parole approved, the stage is set for a fascinating noir. But it never develops. “Stone” starts as a thriller that becomes less interesting as it goes along. Just as you expect it to take a twist or turn, it spins its wheels. I love movies that do something different but “Stone” doesn’t do anything much at all. It’s a film with a final act that doesn’t build enough on what came before — it merely fizzles out.

There are elements of “Stone” that work, especially on second viewing, and my initial review may have been a little harsh. I still think the finale is pretentious and messy but the strength of the cast carries the first two acts. The quartet, especially the movie-stealing Jovovich, do strong work here. They make it worth a rental on a snowy day, but it’s certainly not the home run we used to expect when powerhouses like Norton and De Niro shared a frame.

The lackluster Blu-ray release for “Stone” doesn’t help a second appraisal of the film. I was hoping for some insight via commentary or in-depth examination of the work but there’s just a measly making-of piece without much depth at all. The featurette runs barely over 6 minutes in length. Even the worst films of the year deserve more bonus material. As many problems as I had with “Stone,” it deserved better than this bare-bones treatment.

Special Features:
o Making Of
o Trailers

“Stone” stars Robert De Niro, Edward Norton, Frances Conroy, and Milla Jovovich. It was written by Angus MacLachlan and directed by John Curran. It is rated R and runs 105 minutes. Anchor Bay released it on Blu-ray and DVD on January 18th, 2011. content director Brian Tallerico

Content Director

marten de vries's picture

stone blu ray review

I have to say I disagree with this review, Stone was one of the most underrated films of the year. A great story of spiritual enlightenment and it shows that the first impressions you have of people might not be the right one. Stone and the american were my favourites of the year. I could care less about all those films who got nominated for the golden globes.

BJ's picture


My friend and I loved Stone, he and I are psychology majors, love to watch Criminal Minds, and analyze the subtle nuances, paradoxes, contradictions and inconsistencies of people; the fatal/tragic flaws.

We loved Stone, he was more spiritually and intellectually honest/authentic and likeable as a criminal than the self-lying/deceptive/holier than thou, church going parole officer Jack. He also was trying to improve himself,
get closer to god, etc. Jack just wallowed in his own misery.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

User Login

Free Giveaway Mailing


Advertisement on Twitter

archive Top Ten Discussions