‘Novitiate’ Goes Inside the 1960s Catholic Church

Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly versionE-mail page to friendE-mail page to friendPDF versionPDF version
Average: 5 (1 vote)
HollywoodChicago.com Oscarman rating: 3.5/5.0
Rating: 3.5/5.0

CHICAGO – In a “mystery of faith” narrative disguised as a feminist statement, the new film “Novitiate” goes inside a nunnery in 1964 America, just as the Catholic Church was about to make some radical changes to their procedures. How it affected the church is how it affected the nuns, and the intriguing insider story is full of back room shocks.

The title refers to being a “novice” nun, as the main character is, and it follows her journey through her calling – and the background in her life that led to it – all the way to the point when she lives her vows. This film goes deep, both into the methods of the novice years and the backlash to them. It is anchored by one of the best actors working today, Melissa Leo as the Reverend Mother. The tics and anger she puts into this character are both insane and justified (at least in the universe of the character’s soul). This is a must-see for those practicing the Catholic faith, as a history lesson, and for outsiders it provides a glimpse into the strange and ritualistic mannerisms of an ancient rite of passage.

Cathleen Harris (Margaret Qualley) is a 17 year old girl in 1964. In flashbacks, her problematic childhood is shown – her father abandons the family, her mother (Julianne Nicholson) is bewildered and depressed, plus by happenstance her younger self ends up in a Catholic school, although she isn’t Catholic. Within those gates, she finds her “calling,” and decides to become a nun, much to the horror of her mother.

Sister Cathleen (Margaret Qualley) Gets to a Nunnery in ‘Novitiate’
Photo credit: Sony Pictures Classics

The type of nunnery Cathleen joins is one where the participants worship God and Jesus all day, and have radical silence and punishment techniques. It is controlled with an iron ruler by the Reverend Mother (Melissa Leo), who demands perfect obedience, but is distressed by the news of Vatican II changes. Meanwhile, the class of novices are having issues, which includes the now Sister Cathleen, who is feeling a pull of something else besides her vows.

The indoctrination of human beings into extreme faith and obedience is what makes this movie so fascinating. Writer/director Margaret Betts goes inside this last gasp era of isolation for nuns, creating a metaphor for the world at large, so changed by the revolutions of the 1960s. It also stands to reason that nuns were feminists… they lived within their matriarchal society, obeying their sense of deity rather than earthly dogmas of the church patriarchy. When this collapsed under Vatican II, it emphasizes how unreasonable papal leadership was towards women, especially their women.

The girls of the Novitiate class are interesting to observe as well. They are too young, without any life experience, making decisions about the isolating meditation of absolute acquiescence. Director Betts wisely shows the breakdown of this hasty youthful decision. Sexual urges, without anywhere to act on them, start to emerge. Misunderstandings, including a wrong look, could get an extreme punishment from Reverend Mother, which also ends up a bit kinky. There are some funky and consequential elements to this nunnery, and the story never blinks in exposing them.

Melissa Leo as Reverend Mother in ‘Novitiate’
Photo credit: Sony Pictures Classics

But by going on the inside, there is a distance between the machinations of the girl’s training and their humanity, which caused a disconnect for me. Also the setting of the 1960s, based on the atmosphere of the nunnery and the flashbacks, didn’t feel authentic. But Melissa Leo was an Oscar worthy revelation, injecting a vulnerability into the toughness of the Reverend Mother, where even in her cruelty there is an understanding to her motives.

I am a recovering Catholic, but even all these years later the sense of the church still torments me, which made “Novitiate” that much more of a required viewing. You can declare, as I did within an inner decision making process, that the indoctrination received is no longer a factor in life, but at times it still can’t be shook from consciousness. THAT is the real mystery of the faith.

”Novitiate” continues its nationwide release in Chicago on November 3rd. See local listings for theaters and show times. Featuring Melissa Leo, Margaret Qualley, Julianne Nicholson, Eline Powell and Denis O’Hare. Written and directed by Margaret Betts. Rated “R”

HollywoodChicago.com senior staff writer Patrick McDonald

Writer, Editorial Coordinator

© 2017 Patrick McDonald, HollywoodChicago.com

User Login

Free Giveaway Mailing


  • It's NOT ALL About You John Michael

    CHICAGO – John Michael epitomizes the art of the monologue. The Chicago transplant, by way of Dallas, is moving on (he says temporarily) from the city that inspired his last show, “Meatball Seance,” after notorious and successful runs of his other one-man shows, “John Michael and the Order of the Penix” and “Dementia Me.” His farewell performance is his latest, another laugh riot, “It’s NOT ALL About You John Michael,” and will take place at Mary’s Attic in Chicago’s Andersonville neighborhood on March 1st, 2019. Click here for details, including ticket information.

  • Soccer Player in the Closet, The 2

    CHICAGO – Connecting to the theater collective Nothing Without a Company means a couple of things. One, you may visit parts of Chicago you’ve never seen before – in this case a plant store in an industrial area south of Humboldt Park – and two, you will see some daring and outside-the-box stagings. “The Soccer Player in the Closet” is their latest production – a World Premiere – and it provides what the title implies and beyond. The play runs through March 17th, 2019. Click here for more details, including ticket information.


HollywoodChicago.com on Twitter


HollywoodChicago.com Top Ten Discussions