CHICAGO – Different isn’t bad and might be great, but you’d better have an irrefutable reason to change what was never broken. Campy being the only word to accurately convey this alternate-reality version of Sherlock Holmes with an original script, writer Greg Kramer and director Andrew Shaver try too hard to be different without ever figuring out why.
Blu-ray Feature: The 10 Best Blu-rays of 2012
CHICAGO – It’s that wonderful time of year when we look back on the 11 months that just sped by and try to capture what was best, worst, overlooked, and more. While most of these pieces will just make people disagree, our annual cavalcade of year-end features starts with a piece that you can use to do your holiday shopping!
These were the best Blu-ray releases of 2012, a year that saw a bit of a plateau in the technology but still produced enough quality to make a top 20 easy to produce.
First, a few notes.
Considering how easy it would be simply to make a top ten list that was comprised entirely of Criterion Collection Blu-rays, the tough decision was made to eliminate them entirely from contention. While it would be unfair to include them as they’d probably take up at least half the list, it seems just as unfair to ignore them entirely. And so here are the ten best Criterion Blu-rays of 2012, all must-owns for true movie fans
“Anatomy of a Murder”
“Children of Paradise”
“David Lean Directs Noel Coward”
“The Gold Rush”
“In the Mood For Love”
“Trilogy of Life”
And while we’re limiting ourselves to Blu-ray releases for this feature, it would be a tragedy not to mention the best DVD-only releases of the year: Shout Factory’s great ode to one of the best writer/directors of all time in “The Incredible Mel Brooks” and Music Box Films’ exhaustive chronicle in “The Story of Film.”
The Best Blu-rays of 2012
Runner-Ups: “The Cabin in the Woods,” “The Deer Hunter,” “Deliverance,” “E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial,” “Lethal Weapon Collection,” “Monty Python and the Holy Grail,” “ParaNorman,” “Prometheus,” “The Town: Ultimate Collector’s Edition,” and “The Walking Dead: Season Two”.
10. “The Muppets”
Photo credit: Disney
The most joyful film of the last several years was treated justly with this excellent multi-disc release that offered fans a chance to take Kermit, Miss Piggy, Fozzie, and Walter on the road with not only DVD, Blu-ray, and digital copies of this hysterical film but a code to download the fantastic soundtrack. With deleted scenes, a clever audio commentary, a blooper reel, and a history on the work it took to get Jim Henson’s legendary creation back to the screen, this is the best family Blu-ray release of a new movie for 2012.
9. “Battle Royale: The Complete Collection”
Battle Royale: The Complete Collection
Photo credit: Anchor Bay
It took decades to get here and the film adaptation of a work often considered inspired by it (“The Hunger Games”) to get “Battle Royale” a stateside home release of any kind but the wait was worth it. The four-disc special edition of the spectacular “Battle Royale” was the best foreign language film Blu-ray release of the year, offering multiple versions of the modern classic and hours of special footage. To be fair, the remastering here could have been a little better (and only the inferior Director’s Cut includes a Dolby TrueHD 7.1 audio track) but just being able to own “Battle Royale” on Blu-ray at all is a victory.
Photo credit: Paramount
One of the best films of the most important period in movie history was perfectly restored for the Blu-ray arrival of Roman Polanski’s “Chinatown,” a film that looks so good in HD that it could have come out last week (and it would have been the best movie of 2012). The transfer alone would have earned mention in a feature like this one but when you add to this release a new commentary track that features Robert Towne and David Fincher along with a spectacular new appreciation of the film featuring some notable creative voices commenting on the film’s influence on their career. “Chinatown: An Appreciation” includes Kimberly Peirce, Steven Soderbergh, Roger Deakins, and more. Both features ALONE would make “Chinatown” a must-own. Add them to the previously available features that include interviews with Roman Polanski, Jack Nicholson, and more, and the perfect HD transfer, and you have one of the best classic movie Blu-rays of 2012.
7. “Star Trek: The Next Generation — Season One”
Star Trek: The Next Generation — Season One
Photo credit: Paramount
When Paramount decided to upgrade their beloved “Star Trek: The Next Generation” for the HD fan base, they knew they would have to go above and beyond for customers who not only owned every episode of Captain Picard’s universal adventures but had seen them multiple times. They’d never seen them like THIS. The upgraded special effects earned this release a ton of warranted publicity but it was the little things that really elevated it. Just watching Picard on the bridge looks amazing. And the remastered sound is incredible. Finally, the show has held up dramatically in ways for which it rarely gets the credit it deserves. Right from the very beginning, “The Next Generation” was delivering the kind of intellectual, engaging sci-fi screenwriting that is just too rare in today’s TV market. It would be popular and spectacular if it debuted today, a quarter-century after it actually started. And it would look just about this good.
Photo credit: Disney
Another year, another Disney classic release on my Blu-ray top ten. Can you blame me? Disney does such amazing work with their most beloved films, not only offering fans new special features but HD remasterings that make the upgrade from DVD to Blu-ray easier to justify. Years from now, the Disney classic Blu-ray releases will be looked at as game-changers when it comes to animation in HD. The movie is more visually accomplished than most Blu-rays of films that were theatrically released last year. Admittedly, most of the best special features are material that has been imported from previous releases (although the new short “Tangled Ever After” is pretty cute) but it’s that gorgeously-mixed transfer that pushes it up this list as the best animated Blu-ray of 2012.