CHICAGO – The legacy of public housing is one of the strangest forces of karma in the City of Chicago. For example, sites that were once some of the roughest and most neglected housing for the poor now contain luxury condos. It is the people of those former hellholes that still remember the sorrowful history of what they once called home. The American Theater Company (ATC) have gathered these stories for the poignant and extraordinary “The Projects.”
TV Review: Strong Cast Drives AMC’s Inconsistent ‘Hell on Wheels’
CHICAGO – Do you know what separates AMC from a majority of networks? The art of the ensemble. The multi-Emmy-winning casts of “Mad Men” and “Breaking Bad” are the bars against which most current dramas are measured. There were issues with some of the writing behind “The Killing” but no one ever complained about the performances. And it’s the people of “The Walking Dead” that keep it interesting.
Television Rating: 3.0/5.0
And then there’s “Hell on Wheels,” which returns for its second season tonight, August 12, 2012. It’s a show that proves that even a strong ensemble can only get you so far. I increasingly like the cast of this show, particularly the charismatic actor (and incredibly talented rapper) Common, but the writing still leaves something to be desired.
Hell on Wheels
Photo credit: AMC
When we return to the world of the Union Pacific railroad, Cullen Bohannon (Anson Mount) has joined forces with a group of train robbers who cross paths with Elam (Common), now charged with protecting things like the payroll for the railroad workers. Lily (Dominique McElligott) is closer to the nefarious Doc (Colm Meaney) while the world around the construction seems increasingly full of death and pain.
Hell on Wheels
Photo credit: AMC
“Hell on Wheels” is a dirty, grim, dark show. People at the bottom of the economic and social ladder fall off and die. There’s rarely anyone there to protect them. On a writing level, the parallels between a growing society around a railroad and our modern recession that leaves so many workers hoping for more but not finding it is the strongest element of the show. Thematically, “Hell on Wheels” is interesting stuff (not just in the economic issues but the civil rights ones that still have echoes in 2012).
It’s in plot and character where the show falters. The plotting is often too deliberately slow and remarkably self-serious — something that only works on a show like “Deadwood” where the characters are strong enough to carry the lack of action. Such is not the case here. Common steals every scene he’s in and Dominique McElligot is engaging but I find the villainous Colm Meaney two-dimensional and too much of the rest of the supporting cast forgettable. Lead Anson Mount does his best to find the charisma needed for his character but he’s not given enough chances to display it, especially in the slow premiere.
“Hell on Wheels” doesn’t have enough of a tonal identity. The producers seem to adore shots of hooded train robbers holding their guns in the air but the show isn’t stylish enough overall to make the image resonate. Dialogue scenes often go on too long and feel repetetive while other character actions might come across as underdeveloped. It’s just inconsistent.
Having said that, the cast is strong enough that “Hell on Wheels” could find the track again. Common should be a TV, movie, and (even bigger) music star. He rules. Mount needs to be able to play the hero that it feels like he easily could. And the writing staff needs to decide what they’re making — an old-fashioned Western, a gritty drama, a poetic ode to a lost time, or none of the above. Figure out the tempo of “Hell on Wheels” and let the talented ensemble play to it.